Butterscotch Pie Recipe: 9 Secrets to This Rich & Creamy Classic

Name: Butterscotch Pie Recipe: 9 Secrets to This Rich & Creamy Classic
Prep time: 3 h
Cook time: 40 min
Total time: 9 h 40 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 1 unbaked Flaky or All-Butter Pie Crust; 1 large egg + 1 tbsp milk (for optional egg wash); ¾ cup (150g) packed dark brown sugar; 3 tbsp (24g) cornstarch; 1¼ cups (300ml) whole milk, at room temp; 4 large egg yolks, at room temp; ⅓ cup (67g) granulated sugar; 3 tbsp (45ml) water; 1 cup (240ml) heavy cream, at room temp; 2 tbsp (28g) unsalted butter, softened; ½ tsp salt; 1 tsp pure vanilla extract; 1 tsp bourbon, scotch, or rum (optional; or use more vanilla); 1 cup (240ml) heavy cream, cold; 2 tbsp (25g) dark brown sugar; ½ tsp vanilla extract; Salted caramel sauce (optional, for topping)

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

🥧 Introduction: A Slice of Nostalgia in Every Bite

If there’s one dessert that whispers sweet childhood memories and holiday warmth, it’s a butterscotch pie. Velvety, rich, and packed with the deep caramel flavor of dark brown sugar, this custard-filled beauty is more than just a pie—it’s a time machine on a plate. Whether it reminds you of Grandma’s Sunday table or your favorite old-school diner, butterscotch pie delivers pure comfort in every forkful.

What sets this dessert apart isn’t just its flavor—it’s the journey of creating it. From caramelizing sugar into a golden elixir to gently folding whipped cream over a chilled custard base, every step is a delicious labor of love. And the best part? It’s a perfect make-ahead butterscotch pie recipe, ideal for stress-free holiday planning or impressing guests on a casual weekend.

In this recipe, we’ll guide you through each layer—from flaky crust to that fluffy whipped topping—plus tips, variations, and everything you need to know to master this homemade butterscotch pie. Whether you’re an experienced baker or looking for your next kitchen challenge, this is the pie to bookmark, bake, and boast about.

❓ What is Butterscotch Pie?

Butterscotch pie is a rich, custard-based dessert known for its deep caramel flavor and silky-smooth texture. Unlike overly sweet cream pies, this classic treat gets its complexity from dark brown sugar that’s cooked and caramelized, creating bold molasses notes that pair beautifully with a buttery crust and airy whipped topping.

The filling is typically made by slowly heating brown sugar with cream and egg yolks to create a luscious pudding-like custard. Once cooled and set in a pre-baked pie crust, it’s crowned with freshly whipped cream and often drizzled with a bit of caramel sauce. The result? A perfectly balanced dessert that’s sweet, salty, creamy, and crisp all at once.

🥧 The Legacy of Butterscotch in American Desserts

Butterscotch has deep roots in American kitchens, often seen in candies, puddings, and sauces dating back to the early 1900s. While butterscotch pie may not be as universally known as its chocolate or lemon cousins, it’s a hidden gem among vintage recipes—making a major comeback thanks to retro dessert revivals.

This pie captures the essence of homemade desserts from a bygone era—think glass pie dishes, handwritten recipe cards, and potluck dinners. It’s ideal for those who want to bring a touch of nostalgia to their modern dessert table.

🆚 Butterscotch Pie vs. Similar Custard Pies

Dessert	Flavor Profile	Crust Type	Topping
Butterscotch Pie	Deep caramel, molasses	Flaky butter crust	Whipped cream
Chocolate Cream Pie	Rich cocoa, bittersweet	Graham or flaky	Whipped cream
Banana Cream Pie	Light, fruity, creamy	Vanilla wafer or flaky	Whipped cream
Chess Pie	Eggy, ultra-sweet custard	Shortcrust	None or powdered sugar

What makes butterscotch pie unique is its bold flavor—intensified by caramelization—and its elegant balance of sweetness and creaminess.

🛒 Ingredients for Butterscotch Pie: The Building Blocks of Flavor

Creating the perfect butterscotch pie is all about layering flavors and textures. Here’s a breakdown of each component, why it matters, and how to get the best results.

🥧 A. The Crust: Your Buttery Base

✅ You’ll Need:

1 unbaked Flaky Pie Crust or All-Butter Pie Crust
(Optional) Egg wash: 1 large egg beaten with 1 tbsp milk

A flaky, sturdy pie crust is the essential foundation for this creamy dessert. A homemade all-butter crust offers unmatched flavor and structure, especially when blind-baked properly. Avoid crumb crusts—while tasty, they simply don’t hold up under the soft, silky filling of a butterscotch pie.

🔄 Substitute Tip: You can use a high-quality store-bought pie crust, but make sure to blind bake it completely to prevent sogginess. Skip crumb crusts like graham or pretzel—they’ll crumble under the filling.

🍮 B. The Butterscotch Filling: Where the Magic Happens

✅ Ingredients:

¾ cup (150g) dark brown sugar (light brown works, but dark is better)
3 tbsp (24g) cornstarch
1¼ cups (300ml) whole milk, at room temperature
4 large egg yolks, at room temperature
⅓ cup (67g) granulated sugar
3 tbsp (45ml) water, at room temperature
1 cup (240ml) heavy cream, at room temperature
2 tbsp (28g) unsalted butter, softened
½ tsp salt
1 tsp pure vanilla extract
1 tsp bourbon, scotch, or rum (optional but highly recommended)

This custard is the heart of the butterscotch pie. Using dark brown sugar intensifies the butterscotch flavor, while the cornstarch and egg yolks provide a luscious, spoonable texture. The heavy cream gives it richness, and the optional alcohol adds depth and sophistication.

🔄 No Booze? Just swap in an extra teaspoon of vanilla if you prefer to skip the bourbon or rum.
⚠️ No low-fat substitutions! Skimping on fat here will compromise the custard’s ability to set.

🍦 C. Whipped Cream Topping: Fluffy, Light, and Optional (But Not Really)

✅ Ingredients:

1 cup (240ml) heavy cream, cold
2 tbsp (25g) dark brown sugar
½ tsp vanilla extract
(Optional) Salted caramel sauce, for drizzling

Sweetened with a bit of brown sugar, this whipped cream ties the entire dessert together. Unlike plain whipped cream, the brown sugar enhances the molasses notes in the pie and adds a hint of color.

🎨 Garnish Idea: Drizzle salted caramel sauce or sprinkle on some flaky sea salt for a gourmet finish.

Ingredients for homemade butterscotch pie arranged on a wooden kitchen counter.” — **Don’t miss out—share and pin this recipe on Pinterest today!**

👩‍🍳 Step-by-Step Instructions: How to Make Butterscotch Pie Like a Pro

Mastering butterscotch pie may look intimidating, but with a bit of planning and patience, you’ll be rewarded with one of the most indulgent, nostalgic desserts around. Let’s break down the process into manageable, detailed steps.

🔪 Step 1: Make the Pie Dough (At Least 2 Hours Ahead)

Whether using a flaky homemade crust or an all-butter version, prepare the dough and chill it for a minimum of 2 hours. Cold dough is key to a tender, non-shrinking crust.

💡 Pro Tip: Most homemade pie crust recipes yield two crusts. Wrap and freeze the second one for later use—it’s perfect for a future pumpkin or pecan pie.

🧊 Step 2: Roll Out and Shape the Crust

Roll your chilled dough into a 12-inch circle. Gently transfer it to a 9-inch pie dish, pressing it into the sides without stretching. Fold excess dough over to form a thick edge, then crimp or flute as desired.

🧵 Crimping Hack: If the dough gets too soft to shape, chill it in the fridge for 5–10 minutes before continuing.

Refrigerate the shaped crust for at least 30 minutes before baking. Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Line the crust with parchment paper and fill with pie weights or dried beans. Bake for 15–16 minutes until the edges brown slightly.

Remove the weights and paper, prick the bottom with a fork, and return to the oven for another 14–15 minutes. For a glossy finish, brush the edges with egg wash before this second bake.

⚠️ Do Not Skip Blind Baking! The butterscotch custard is very soft—blind baking ensures the crust stays crisp and holds its shape.

🍯 Step 4: Make the Butterscotch Custard Filling

In a bowl, whisk together:

Dark brown sugar, cornstarch, milk, and egg yolks

In a saucepan:

Cook granulated sugar and water over medium heat until amber in color (about 5–7 minutes). Do not stir—swirl the pan instead.
Slowly whisk in the heavy cream—it will bubble violently, so be careful.
Once smooth, pour in the brown sugar mixture slowly, whisking constantly.

Heat until the mixture thickens and large bubbles burst (about 5 minutes or until it reaches 195–200°F). Remove from heat and stir in butter, salt, vanilla, and bourbon (or more vanilla).

🥧 Step 5: Fill and Chill

Pour the warm custard into the cooled, blind-baked crust and smooth it out. Let it cool for 5 minutes at room temp, then refrigerate uncovered for at least 6 hours (or overnight). After that, press plastic wrap directly on the surface to prevent condensation.

❄️ Make-Ahead Friendly: This pie can be made up to 2 days in advance and stored in the fridge without whipped topping.

🍦 Step 6: Whip the Cream and Finish

When ready to serve, beat together:

Heavy cream
Brown sugar
Vanilla extract

Whip to medium peaks (soft but holds shape). Pipe or spread over the chilled pie. For extra flair, drizzle salted caramel sauce or sprinkle with flaky sea salt.

🍴 Step 7: Slice and Serve

Use a sharp knife and wipe between slices for clean cuts. Serve chilled and enjoy the layers of flavor you’ve built—from buttery crust to that silky, luxurious custard.

📦 Storage Tip: Leftovers keep in the fridge for up to 5 days. Don’t freeze after topping with whipped cream.

Pouring rich butterscotch custard into a pre-baked pie crust.” — **Don’t miss out—share and pin this recipe on Pinterest today!**

💡 Tips & Variations: Mastering Butterscotch Pie Your Way

Whether you’re baking butterscotch pie for the first time or you’re already obsessed, these expert tips and creative twists will take your dessert game to the next level.

🔧 Pro Tips for Butterscotch Pie Success

🕒 1. Plan Ahead

This pie isn’t last-minute—factor in time for chilling the crust and the finished pie (at least 6 hours!). Consider making it a day in advance for stress-free serving.

🔥 2. Be Patient with the Sugar

When caramelizing sugar, resist the urge to stir! Let it bubble and swirl occasionally. Stirring too soon can cause crystallization, leading to a grainy filling.

🧊 3. Room Temperature Ingredients = Smoother Custard

Make sure your milk, egg yolks, and cream are all at room temp before starting. This helps the custard blend more smoothly and prevents curdling.

🍽️ 4. Use the Right Tools

A heavy-bottomed saucepan, instant-read thermometer, and offset spatula will make your life easier. Temperature precision is key for a pudding that sets properly.

🎨 Variations: Customize Your Butterscotch Pie

🥃 1. Boozy Butterscotch Pie

Add an extra teaspoon of bourbon, scotch, or dark rum to intensify the flavor. The alcohol cooks off, leaving a sophisticated depth that pairs beautifully with the caramel notes.

🍌 2. Butterscotch Banana Cream Pie

Line the crust with sliced bananas before pouring in the custard. Adds fruitiness and texture—especially popular with kids!

🥜 3. Nut Lover’s Butterscotch Pie

Sprinkle toasted pecans or walnuts over the whipped cream topping. The crunch complements the creamy filling and adds visual appeal.

🍫 4. Chocolate-Dipped Crust Edge

Brush melted dark chocolate onto the crust rim before filling. It adds a fancy finish and helps keep the crust crisp.

💬 Bonus Tip: Want to add crunch? Serve slices with a sprinkle of crushed toffee or a shard of caramelized sugar on top.

❓ Butterscotch Pie FAQs: Your Top 10 Questions Answered

1. Can I use a store-bought crust for butterscotch pie?

Yes! A store-bought crust works fine as long as you blind bake it properly. This step is essential to prevent a soggy bottom and ensure your butterscotch pie holds up when sliced.

2. Why shouldn’t I use a graham cracker or pretzel crust?

Although tasty, crumb crusts don’t provide the structural integrity needed for a soft custard like butterscotch pie. They tend to crumble when sliced, which makes for messy servings.

3. How far in advance can I make butterscotch pie?

You can prepare the entire butterscotch pie up to two days in advance. Store it covered in the fridge without the whipped topping. Add the topping right before serving for the freshest look and taste.

4. Can I freeze butterscotch pie?

Yes, but freeze it before adding whipped cream. Wrap the cooled pie tightly with plastic wrap and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before topping and serving.

5. Can I make it without alcohol?

Definitely. Just substitute the alcohol (bourbon, scotch, or rum) with an extra teaspoon of vanilla extract. You’ll still get a deliciously rich and creamy butterscotch pie without the booze.

6. Is it possible to make this recipe gluten-free?

Yes. Simply use a gluten-free pie crust—either homemade or store-bought. The butterscotch filling itself is naturally gluten-free (just make sure your cornstarch is certified GF).

7. Can I use low-fat milk or non-dairy milk?

We don’t recommend it. Whole milk and heavy cream are essential for the custard to set properly. Skipping the full-fat dairy could result in a runny butterscotch pie.

8. How will I know when the custard is ready?

Your butterscotch filling is done when it reaches 195–200°F and large bubbles begin to break the surface. Use an instant-read thermometer for accuracy—don’t guess!

9. Can I use meringue instead of whipped cream?

Yes! For a dramatic twist on the classic butterscotch pie, top it with toasted meringue instead of whipped cream. Just be sure to stabilize the meringue properly (using cream of tartar or a cooked sugar base).

10. What can I do with the leftover egg whites?

You’ll have four egg whites left—perfect for making meringue cookies, macarons, or even an angel food cake. You can also freeze egg whites for up to 3 months for future use.

🥄 Conclusion: The Butterscotch Pie That’s Worth Every Minute

Making a butterscotch pie from scratch is more than just baking—it’s a labor of love layered with buttery crust, golden caramel flavor, and silky-smooth custard. It’s the kind of dessert that earns a permanent place in your recipe box and gets requested year after year during the holidays.

Whether you’re introducing this pie to your dessert lineup or reviving a cherished family favorite, it delivers big flavor, impressive presentation, and nostalgic charm. Plus, it’s a make-ahead wonder—perfect for easing the holiday rush or impressing guests without stress.

So, roll up your sleeves, grab your whisk, and dive into the rich world of homemade butterscotch pie. Your taste buds (and your guests) will thank you.

Have you tried this Butterscotch Pie recipe?

Leave a comment, share it with friends, and follow us on Pinterest for more bake and no-bake dessert inspiration straight to your feed!